12 September 2025
Posted by Paddy Ferguson on 12 September 2025
Introduction
On 2 July 2025, the FCA published a policy statement and consultation paper (CP25/18) concerning non-financial misconduct within the financial services sector.[1] The policy statement confirmed that, from 1 September 2026, the scope of the Code of Conduct (the “COCON”) will be expanded to include a new rule, COCON 1.1.7FR, stating that non-financial misconduct including workplace bullying, harassment and violence within the financial services sector can constitute a regulatory breach. Additionally, the consultation sets out the FCA’s proposed guidance in relation to non-financial misconduct which, if adopted, will come into force alongside it.
The FCA’s Conduct Rules
FCA-regulated firms are governed by a comprehensive framework which ensures that financial services firms are run by competent, accountable individuals who act with integrity. This includes the Senior Managers and Certification Regime (the “SMCR”), the COCON, and the Fit and Proper person requirements.
The SMCR sets out the structure and scope of regulated roles. The COCON is a set of rules which sets the minimum standard of individual behaviour expected of individuals in the UK working for FCA-authorised financial services firms subject to the SMCR. The COCON operates in parallel with the Fit and Proper requirements for senior managers and certified persons under the SMCR, which ensure that individuals meet the necessary standards to perform their roles effectively and ethically.
As such, in updating COCON and consulting in relation to guidance concerning non-financial misconduct, the FCA is setting an ethical and behavioural standard which individuals in applicable firms must meet in order to work in the regulated sector, and to which those firms must hold their staff accountable. COCON 1.1.7FR concerns non-financial misconduct, which indicates clearly that the FCA is not only concerned with the manner in which regulated persons carry out their work, but also with the probity of individuals in applicable roles.
Who will the rules apply to?
Whereas non-financial misconduct rules previously only applied to banks, the new rules will apply to regulated firms with Part 4A permission, and so will apply to an estimated 37,000 non-bank financial services firms[2], including investment firms, wealth managers, insurance companies and mortgage lenders and brokers. It will also apply to all staff within those firms who are subject to COCON.
When will the rules apply?
COCON 1.1.7FR will take effect from 1 September 2026. Therefore, regulated firms have some time to prepare for the new rule.
The FCA has clarified that the new rule will not apply retrospectively and that it does not expect a firm to “do any retrospective analysis of whether it has incorrectly determined a conduct rule breach in the past”. However, the new rule will require any non-financial misconduct to be included in regulatory references, thereby countering the so-called practice of “rolling bad apples” and preventing rule-breakers from simply moving between firms to avoid being reported to the FCA and facing any regulatory enforcement action in respect of breaches of the conduct rules.
Consultation:
Alongside the rule change, the FCA has opened a consultation in relation to potential new Handbook guidance aimed at helping SMCR firms to interpret and consistently apply the COCON and to clarify requirements for fitness and propriety of regulated persons, including in relation to non-financial misconduct outside the workplace. While the FCA has confirmed that firms are not required to monitor their employees’ private lives, they are nevertheless expected to consider events outside work, such as criminal convictions, allegations or posts on social media, when assessing the fitness and propriety of their employees.
The deadline to respond to the consultation is 10 September 2025. The FCA has indicated that if it does publish Handbook guidance, it would look to do so by the end of 2025 in order to allow firms good time to update their processes before the rule change comes into effect on 1 September 2026.
What constitutes non-financial misconduct under COCON 1.1.7FR and under the fit and proper test?
The FCA has clarified that it is concerned with serious misconduct which has a significant negative effect on the subject, and that minor incidents of poor workplace behaviour should not be brought unnecessarily into scope of the rules. Serious misconduct is conduct which has the purpose of effect of violating a person’s dignity, of creating an intimidating, hostile, degrading, humiliating or offensive environment, or which is violent. Non-financial misconduct therefore includes but is not limited to conduct which would breach the Equality Act 2010.
Misconduct towards colleagues, service providers and consultants which is committed in the workplace will breach the new rule. Whether or not the misconduct arose in the course of the performance of regulated activities is irrelevant. In an attempt to avoid confusion, the FCA has provided examples of when a person’s conduct is outside the scope of COCON because it is part of their private or personal life, rather than committed in the course of their employment, and when it is not excluded for that reason at 1.3.7 of its draft guidance. However, in practice, it is likely that firms will have to make judgment calls on whether to report instances of non-financial misconduct which may be in breach of the COCON to the FCA. This may, at least initially, lead to inconsistencies among SMCR firms in relation to the types of incidents which are reported.
Notably, other forms of misconduct which do not occur in the workplace may be relevant to a fitness and propriety assessment. Indeed, if the proposed guidance is published, non-financial misconduct will have to be considered in connection with the fitness and propriety assessment of SMCR employees. The guidance states that dishonesty, lack of integrity, violence or sexual misconduct may prevent a person from being considered fit and proper.
In explaining its proposed guidance, the FCA has clarified that, while it does not expect firms to monitor their employees’ private lives to identify anything that is relevant to fitness, a firm may become aware of information about an individual’s private life that would – if substantiated – call into question their fitness and propriety. In these circumstances, the firm should consider what steps it can reasonably take to assess this possible impact. This is because fitness and propriety requirements apply to all relevant matters wherever in the world they occur. This means that firms sometimes have to consider events outside work, such as criminal convictions, allegations or posts on social media. Conduct in one’s private life may be relevant to one’s fitness and propriety assessment if it shows a willingness to disregard ethical or legal obligations, abuse a position of trust or exploit others’ vulnerabilities.
The FCA holds that a person can lawfully express in their private or personal life their views on social media, even if those views are controversial or offensive and even if work colleagues are upset by those views, without calling into question their fitness. However, if a person’s social media activity in their private life indicates a real risk that the person will breach the requirements and standards of the regulatory system, then such activity will be relevant to their fitness and propriety.
There have been various examples of regulated persons being censured by the FCA in relation to non-financial misconduct. Perhaps most notably, in June 2025, Jes Stanley, who acted as CEO of Barclays from 2015 until 2021, was banned from holding senior management roles in the financial services industry and fined £1.1 million (a reduction from the £1.8 million fine proposed by the FCA)[3].
Mr Staley’s ban related to misleading statements made in a letter from the Barclays Chairman, but approved by Mr Staley, to the FCA about the nature of Mr Staley’s relationship with Jeffrey Epstein and their last point of contact. The matter was referred to the Upper Tribunal, which found that Mr Staley had acted with a lack of integrity, had failed to be open and co-operative and had failed to make appropriate disclosures to the FCA.
Implications for Senior Management
Significant emphasis is placed on managers’ responsibility to implement robust procedures to prevent any breaches of non-financial misconduct rules. The guidance states that a manager’s failure to prevent bullying, harassment and other forms of non-financial misconduct may constitute a breach of COCON 2 – which requires individuals to act with due skill, care and diligence – unless the manager has acted reasonably. The guidance further provides a non-exhaustive list of examples of a manager’s conduct which would breach COCON 2, which includes:
A breach of COCON 2 may result in public censure, financial penalties, or even a suspension or prohibition from acting in a regulated role.
As such, there is a clear incentive for managers to act proactively to ensure that their firms have adequate processes and procedures in place to prevent and, if necessary, address non-financial misconduct in the workforce.
How should firms prepare?
The FCA has observed that poor market conduct or consumers being failed by financial services firms are too often correlated to cultural failure within firms, and that one of the clearest signs of a failing culture is non-financial misconduct. Non-financial misconduct and discriminatory practices in firms are relevant to its assessment of firms’ suitability to undertake regulated activities. Therefore, should a regulated firm fail to foster a positive working environment and to develop an integrous workforce, it would be at risk of losing is authorisation to undertake controlled activities.
There are a number of steps which firms should be taking now, including the following:
Conclusion
The new rule and, if published, the accompanying Handbook guidance will apply to a very large number of financial services firms. Both those firms and their managers will bear individual and collective responsibility to oversee compliance with the new requirements. The penalties for non-compliance may be severe. Therefore, although we are still many months away from the changes taking effect, firms would be well-advised to use the time now to understand the new requirements and to put robust procedures in place to ensure compliance with the FCA rules and guidance as and when they come into force.
[1] CP25/18: Tackling non-financial misconduct in financial services
[2] FCA clarifies expectations on bullying, harassment and violence to deepen trust in financial services | FCA
