24 July 2025
Posted by Elizabeth Robertson on 24 July 2025
Introduction
On 23 July 2025, the UK Supreme Court (the “UKSC”) overturned the convictions of former city traders Tom Hayes and Carlo Palombo. While they will celebrate the news, they will no doubt now be asking – why did the SFO prosecute them in the first place, and why has it taken 13 years to clear their names?
Background
In August 2015, Tom Hayes was found guilty of conspiracy to defraud by manipulating the London Interbank Offered Rate (“Libor”)[1]. Mr Hayes was sentenced to 14 years’ imprisonment, subsequently reduced to 11 years on appeal. This was one of the toughest sentences for white collar crime ever handed down in the UK. Mr Hayes served five and a half years of his sentence.
In March 2019, Carlo Palombo was found guilty of conspiracy to defraud by manipulating the Euro Interbank Offered Rate (“Euribor”)[2]. Mr Palombo was sentenced to four years’ imprisonment. He served two years of his sentence.
Mr Hayes and Mr Palombo were among nine people successfully prosecuted by the UK Serious Fraud Office (“SFO”) for rigging benchmark rates, and among 19 traders convicted in the UK and the US, of whom nine were jailed.
The UKSC’s Judgment
Mr Hayes and Mr Palombo contended that their convictions depended on a definition of Libor and Euribor which had been adopted during their trials which incorrectly assumed that there was an absolute legal prohibition on a bank’s commercial interests being taken into account when submitting Libor or Euribor rates. The UKSC found that the jury in the original trials had been misdirected when they were told that a Libor rate was inherently not genuine or honest if it had been influenced by a trading advantage. Instead, as set out in Lord Leggatt’s summary of the UKSC judgment, “These were questions of fact which should have been left to the jury to decide”.
Lord Leggatt summarised the judgment stating that while there “was ample evidence on which a jury, properly directed, could have found [Mr Hayes] guilty of conspiracy to defraud”, because the jury was not properly directed, the function of the jury was usurped and it was unable to properly consider a key aspect of Mr Hayes’ defence. Lord Leggatt explained that this made the trial unfair, and as a result, his convictions had to be quashed. The UKSC also held that while the directions given to the jury in Mr Palombo’s case are not open to the same degree of criticism, the judge in that case nevertheless also erred in treating a question of fact as if it were a matter of law, so his conviction is also unsafe and must be quashed.
US Precedent
The UKSC’s decision to overturn the conviction of Mr Hayes and Mr Palombo has been a long time coming. They had unsuccessfully appealed against their convictions in 2015 and 2020 respectively. But, in January 2022, a United States Court of Appeal reversed the conviction of two former Deutsche Bank traders for fraud in the manipulation of Libor rates, ruling that it was not against the law to seek to influence the estimates a bank submits of the cost of borrowing cash. Mr Hayes and Mr Palombo contended that, in doing so, the US court had adopted a different definition of Libor from that used by the English courts in their convictions. This judgment, which directly contradicted the convictions of Mr Hayes and Mr Palombo, left the UK as the only country in the world in which the rate manipulation conduct which Mr Hayes and Mr Palombo were accused of was criminalised. As a result of this judgment, all of the charges against Mr Hayes in the US were dropped.
In light of these developments, the UK Criminal Case Review Commission (the “CCRC”) invited Mr Hayes’ legal representatives to make additional submissions concerning his convictions in the UK. Following a review of these submissions, the CCRC concluded that there was a real possibility that the UK Court of Appeal would prefer the legal approach to the definition and operation of the Libor rules taken by the US Court than those which were reached in Mr Hayes’s own case, and would therefore find that this rendered his conviction unsafe. As such, the CCRC referred Mr Hayes’ conviction to the UK Court of Appeal. This appeal was dismissed in March 2024, but Mr Hayes and Mr Palombo appealed against that decision to the UKSC.
This sequence of events raises question as to why it took the UK courts so long to reach the eventual judgment that the convictions were unsafe and must be quashed.
Commentary
The SFO has released a statement in response to the UKSC judgment which concludes, “We have considered this judgment and the full circumstances carefully and determined it would not be in the public interest for us to seek a retrial”. This is a peculiar statement. Nobody has suggested that a re-trial should be considered. Instead, this should be a moment of profound self-reflection for the SFO. Indeed, there is a fundamental question to be answered: why did the SFO investigate this matter in the first place?
Tom Hayes was arrested in December 2012 in relation to his conduct between 2006 and 2010 and was eventually convicted in August 2015. At the time of Mr Hayes’ arrest, and throughout the period of his and Mr Palombo’s alleged misconduct, banks and traders were regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (the “FCA”). It was the FCA which was responsible for taking enforcement action in relation to alleged misconduct within banks.
Having identified Libor-related systems and controls failures with banks, and breaches of the regulatory principles of market integrity, transparency and proper conduct, the FCA took comprehensive action. Banks including Barclays, RBS, Lloyds Banking Group, UBS, Deutsche Bank and Rabobank and brokers including ICAP were fined a combined total in the UK of over £700 million for Libor-related misconduct. In addition, the FCA implemented structural and supervisory reforms. It introduced new rules in 2015 requiring regulated administrators for interbank benchmarks and supported the transition away from Libor towards risk-free rates. The FCA has also monitored implementation of improved internal controls and compliance frameworks within banks. Additionally, both Mr Hayes and Mr Palombo were banned by the FCA from ever taking part in regulated financial activities in the UK. This represented a stern response from the appropriate regulator.
Notwithstanding the FCA’s action, and despite the SFO having previously backed out of a Libor investigation in 2011 because of concerns that it would drain resources and might duplicate the work of other investigating agencies, it announced that it had formally launched an investigation into the rigging of inter-bank lending rates in July 2012. It did so after it had secured £3.5 million of so-called Blockbuster Funding (a top-up of funds from the Treasury over and above the SFO’s core annual budget to assist with the investigation of high-profile cases). The SFO later secured an additional £19 million in early 2014, before securing a further £26.5 million nine months later.
The SFO investigation faced criticism for this from the likes of the then Shadow Attorney General, Emily Thornberry, who queried the propriety of the agency opening investigations only after the Treasury had topped up its funds, commenting, “It’s not for the Treasury to decide what gets investigated, it’s for the SFO”.
The SFO formally launched its investigation to great fanfare. The Chief Secretary to the Treasury, Danny Alexander, said he was “delighted” by the SFO’s decision to formally investigate, and promised that the government would “make sure the SFO has all the resources it needs to conduct this investigation in full”.
The zeal with which the then-government sent the SFO after Libor and Euribor traders fits the political context at the time. In the wake of the 2008 financial crisis, bankers’ practices (and their bonuses) were firmly under the spotlight, and there was strong political pressure for perpetrators of wrongdoing to face justice, or what passed for it.
Conclusion
It would seem that the sad reflection to be drawn from the UKSC’s decision is that, for a while at least, populism got in the way of justice. It has taken almost ten years for Mr Hayes, and over six years for Mr Palombo, to overturn unsafe convictions. Both men have served years in prison in the meantime. But for the referral from the CCRC in 2023, neither would have been able to appeal to the UKSC. While the UKSC has now delivered a definitive and legally sound judgment, a misguided SFO prosecution caused tremendous disruption to the lives of its targets and cost the taxpayer tens of millions. This sorry story must serve as a cautionary tale going forward. The financial crisis was ruinous. Libor manipulation was deeply unpalatable. Publicly scapegoating a handful of traders, however, was not the solution.
[1] Libor was a benchmark interest rate reflecting the average rate at which major global banks were willing to lend to one another in the London interbank market, calculated daily based on numbers submitted by numerous large banks.
[2] Euribor was a benchmark interest rate reflecting the average rate at which eurozone banks would lend to one another in Euros.
